Hello,
Thank you for asking the followup question.
The way I see it, you got same advice from both the Neuro specialists. The only difference is how to approach it - that is how to stop the drug. There are no standard recommendations in this, so it depends on individual Doctors preference. I would recommend a more traditional approach which will be a middle path. Reduce it to half a tab (50mg) for two weeks and then stop, while under medical supervision.
Honestly I cannot say one approach is better than other because there is not enough data to substantiate any. So the best approach for you will be to fix on a Doctor (preferably a Neurologist than a NeuroSurgeon) and follow his recommendation. This is not a complicated treatment issue at all.
Wishing you a drug free, seizure free productive life.
Hope this helps.
Thank you