Whether surgery is recommended for FRACTURED HUMERUS in XRAY?

Hello,
Thank you for yoiur query at DoctorSpring.com
Thanks for writing to us.
I have read the history & saw the xray.
It is a case of two part fracture of humerus neck region. We have 2 well documented treatment lines for this fracture.
1). Conservative management by hanging slab or brace & shoulder immobiliser.
2). Surgical procedure by plate and screws or Antigrade nailing.
Well, both procedures have its pros and cons. We have good long term results by both techniques in ours orthopedic research analysis. Results also depends on surgical experience of orthopedic Surgeon and patients age & co-morbidities.
I recommend surgical procedure as it allows early mobilisation.
Dear, as a patient you ll not be able to decide by urself. I strongly recommend you to discuss this with your treating surgeon and decide as per his recommendations. I am hopeful that you ll get good results.
Get well soon & stay healthy,
Thanks,

Thank you. Looking at the X-rays, can you explain a little bit the large displacement in one and no displacement in another shot? Does it mean that the fracture is "reset" and muscles are holding it together so it's feasible to heal well if proper immobilization is in place? If that is the case, what kind of cast/sling would you suggest is suitable for best results?

Hello,
Thanks for writing back to us.
Both x-rays appear to be same. Displacement is there at the fracture site in both x-rays but not large one.
As I told you in the previous mail, conservative treatment is well-documented line of treatment which includes proper immobilisation also.
If I don't operate then I suggest Hanging U slab with shoulder immobiliser for you as a conservative treatment but the best decision should be taken by you only after discussing with your treating orthopedic Surgeon.
Get well soon,
Stay happy & healthy